Second visit in as many weeks! The maccheroni and meat balls were each splendid dishes. The service and atmosphere are both two thumbs way up.

What a special place! I am not sure where to start but you can’t go wrong with the food. At all. Across the board. The wait staff can guide you if you aren’t commanding on your own. Signature: steak! Garlic bread! Fava bean salad, ramps, hens of the wood, and the extras -/ vesper, vino, dessert!!!! The place: beet graffiti, and plants cared for deeply. Both bars :) and all the little corner photo ops. The people — collaborating proudly to deliver the finest the village has to offer. Lovely romantic neighborhood vibe.

Superb! The garlic bread is amazing. We did the tasting menu which included 8 dishes in 4 courses. We had 2 vegetable dishes, 2 pasta dishes, meatballs, cod, polenta, and dessert. Every dish was flavorful and carefully thought out for a perfect bite. The desert was also amazing, definitely recommend this restaurant for a date night or small group gathering. The restaurant actually has 2 sections inside so there seemed to be a decent amount of seating/capacity but it’s popular so I recommend a reservation. We have passed by this restaurant many times and didn’t even realize we have been missing out. Will definitely go back.

Great place!! The quality of the food is outstanding and its cooked with care. Our waitress was lots of fun and happy to explain the menu and give recommendations. The wine list was long and they had a very good selection of wine by the glass on the board. Give it a try, I loved it!

My fiance surprised me with a tasting menu dinner at Hearth for my Christmas present. The decor and ambiance were welcoming and tastefully done. The waitstaff was absolutely friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu. Eric, our server, was thorough in explaining the various wine pairings that came along with each of the courses. The food was delicious, artfully prepared, and effused the love that went into preparing it! I had an amazing time and, as a foodie, truly appreciated this opportunity to enjoy a wonderful meal!

Really amazing. Food, drinks, and service were all incredible. Staff was funny and really sweet. We did the restaurant week pre-fix which was the perfect amount of food.

Had one of the most amazing meals of my life here! 100% the best meatball of my life!! Came in a couple weeks I'll go with my boyfriend for dinner during restaurant week. Everything was excellent! Loved the warm crispy crust on the olive oil cake and the bottle of white wine from the Canary Islands!! Our server was great. We had a really nice conversation with the manager or food runner at the end of our meal to top off a perfect evening. I will definitely return when I'm back in NYC.

This place is amazing. Jefferson was one of the best servers I have ever had the opportunity to meet.

The minute we walked in, we all felt like we were in a much better mood, not sure why, they were just so inviting even though we were a little late for our reservation. (We did call in advance to let them know we would be). Our server was simply the loveliest person, so inviting and helpful. We had someone in our party with several allergies and we went over the menu and discussed what would be acceptable to order and she even made an off menu suggestion to accommodate us. Food was just phenomenal, we had the garlic bread, the asparagus, the meatballs, the pasta ragu, a cacio e pepe pasta was made for us since our party could not have the other pasta dish with pesto, and we had the fish. Everything was delicious! Towards the end of the meal, the person with the allergy issues started feeling itchy and had to leave. We went over and over the food items, our server was clearly mortified and was likely more upset than anyone in our party. She went back over the menu with the chef and confirmed that everything we ordered was free of our known allergens. While we do not know what caused the reaction, the restaurant's handling of this situation was 1000% on point. No one in our group had any ill will towards the establishment. (You'll want to know this person went home and to sleep and is perfectly fine, still no idea what caused the reaction, though) I would absolutely return to this restaurant!

Wonderful, cozy place! Great drinks (please forgive me, I do not remember what I had) and great pork chops! Seriously, probably the best pork chops I've had... ever! The bartender was super nice as well :) 4 stars only because we were at the bar and I didn't get a "full" restaurant experience.